Is an email to agree to rent a property legally binding?

I have changed my mind to rent a berth I own for a boat via a broker, as I have sold it privately.

The broker emailed me with details for renting from April 1st. I send an email to agree. Five days later before I had received a contract I emailed to say I had sold the berth and therefore would not proceed to rent it for a year. Is there any come back please as the broker is asking for compensation? That day he received a deposit from his client.

Please advise.

88 viewscommercial law

Alasdair Taylor's Answer

I don’t think there is enough information to be confident of the answer here.

On the hand, it could be an unenforceable “agreement to agree”; on the other, it could be an enforceable contract. A lawyer would want (amongst other things) to discuss the surrounding circumstances and look at the chain of communications before advising.

For background (NB from a US lawyer), see:

Ask a question

Question in one sentence
Select a topic that best fits your question.

Search questions


Using this legal Q&A, users can get guidance on business-related legal questions from our legal experts.

The guidance is not legal advice; no lawyer-client or similar relationship is created by the Q&A.

By using the Q&A, you agree to the limitations and exclusions of liability set out in our terms and conditions.

SEQ Legal
Copyright © 2021 Docular Limited All rights reserved